Showing posts with label Geometry. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Geometry. Show all posts

Thursday, 1 August 2024

Ceva's Theorem

This is a classical result which is very often quite useful. Consider $\triangle ABC$ and three points $P,Q$ and $R$ on $BC, AC$ and $AB$ respectively (segments of this form are called cevians). Then Ceva's theorem states that:
The three cevians $AP, BQ$ and $CR$ are concurrent (meet at a point) if and only if $$\frac{AR}{RB}\frac{BP}{PC}\frac{CQ}{QA}=1$$
The quantity $\frac{AR}{RB}\frac{BP}{PC}\frac{CQ}{QA}$ is called Ceva's Ratio and it is determined upto reciprocal.
Convince yourself by playing with the following GeoGebra applet (use $P, Q$ and $R$, vertices won't change the ratio)


 
Let us first assume the given cevians are concurrent (as shown below):


We will use the fact that ratio of areas of triangles with equal altitudes is equal to ratio of their bases. Area of $\triangle XYZ$ will be denoted as $XYZ$.
$$\frac{ARC}{RBC}=\frac{AR}{RB}=\frac{ARO}{RBO}$$
$$\frac{AR}{RB}=\frac{ARC-ARO}{RBC-RBO}=\frac{ACO}{BCO}$$
Similarly $\frac{BP}{PC}=\frac{BAO}{CAO}$ and $\frac{CQ}{QA}=\frac{CBO}{ABO}$. Thus,
$$\frac{AR}{RB}\frac{BP}{PC}\frac{CQ}{QA}=\frac{ACO}{BCO}\frac{BAO}{CAO}\frac{CBO}{ABO}=1$$
Conversely, assume $\frac{AR}{RB}\frac{BP}{PC}\frac{CQ}{QA}=1$. Suppose $AP$ and $BQ$ meet at $O$. Suppose $CO$ intersect line $AB$ at $R'$ ($R'$ lies on segment $AB$, for more details see below). Then from above, $\frac{AR'}{R'B}\frac{BP}{PC}\frac{CQ}{QA}=1$. Using the given hypothesis,  $\frac{AR'}{R'B}\frac{BP}{PC}\frac{CQ}{QA}=\frac{AR}{RB}\frac{BP}{PC}\frac{CQ}{QA}$ ie. $\frac{AR'}{R'B}=\frac{AR}{RB}$. Since $R$ and $R'$ lie between $A$ and $B$, by uniqueness of internal ratio we have $R=R'$.



PS: Some of the assertions like $R'$ lying on segment $AB$, $O$ being in interior of $\triangle ABC$ or the uniqueness assertion which gives us $R=R'$ need rigorous proof which can be found in George E Martin's book given in the reference. It is not an easy read, so beware.


References:
  • The foundations of geometry and the non-Euclidean plane by George Edward Martin
  • A Sequel to the First Six Books of Euclid by John Casey
  • David Joyce's web version of Euclid's Elements


Saturday, 20 July 2024

The Butterfly Theorem

This is a simple geometric result, first published in early 18th century. 

Consider chord $AB$ in the given circle with midpoint $M$. If $CD$ and $EF$ are two more chords passing through $M$ such that $CF$ and $ED$ meets $AB$ at $G$ and $H$ respectively. Then $M$ is also the midpoint of $GH$.
For our convenience, let $AM = BM =a$, $GM=b$ and $HM=c$. Drop perpendiculars $GG'$, $GG''$, $HH'$ and $HH''$ on $CM, FM, EM$ and $DM$ respectively (and let their lengths be $b',b'',c'$ and $c''$ resp.).  We have shown the construction below:

We now chase the similar triangles. Since $\triangle MG'G \sim \triangle MH''H$ we have $\frac{b}{c} = \frac{b'}{c''}$. Similarly $ \frac{b}{c} = \frac{b''}{c'}$.  Also note $\triangle CG'G \sim \triangle EH'H$ and $\triangle FG''G \sim \triangle DH''H$. So $\frac{b'}{c'} = \frac{CG}{EH}$ and $\frac{b''}{c''} = \frac{FG}{DH}$. So we have, $$\frac{b^2}{c^2}=\frac{b'b''}{c'c''}=\frac{CG \times FG}{DH \times EH}$$Intersecting chords theorem gives us $CG \times FG = AG \times BG=(a-b)(a+b)$ and similarly $DH \times EH = (a-c)(a+c)$. Thus we have $\frac{b^2}{c^2}= \frac{a^2-b^2}{a^2-c^2}$ which easily gives us $b=c$.

References:
  • A Sequel to the First Six Books of Euclid by John Casey
  • David Joyce's web version of Euclid's Elements

Thursday, 29 June 2023

The Nine Point Circle

The nine point circle (also known as Feuerbach's circle) is one of the most interesting topics in elementary geometry. It doesn't require much prerequisites and so this post can be read by a high school student who has some idea about geometry of circle and triangle.

Just a reminder: All three altitudes of a triangle meet at a single point, which we call orthocenter and a set of points is said to be concyclic if they all lie in a circle.






Consider $\triangle ABC$ and let $O$ be the orthocenter (shown in green). Let $A_a$ be the feet of altitude from vertex $A$ on side $BC$, $A_m$ be the midpoint of side $BC$ and $A_o$ be the midpoint of line segment $AO$ (we have used the colors red, blue and orange respectively for these points). Similar notations corresponding to vertex $B$ and $C$. Then the nine points (which sometimes may not be distinct)  $A_o, B_o, C_o$ (midpoints between orthocenter and vertices) $A_m, B_m, C_m$ (midpoints of sides) and $A_a, B_a, C_a$ (feet of altitudes) lie in a same circle which is commonly called the nine point circle (shown with dotted circle).

Try interacting with the GeoGebra applet given below ($\Omega$ is the center of nine point circle):


To prove this we need some elementary results:

  • A convex quadrilateral is cyclic (ie. its vertices are concyclic) if and only if its opposite angles are supplementary (ie. $180^{\circ}$). One half of this result is Euclid's proposition $22$ in Book III.
  • Line segment formed by connecting the midpoints of two sides of a triangle will be parallel to the third side and have half of its length. This called midpoint theorem.
  • The center of the circumcircle of a right triangle lies on its hypotenuse. This is converse of a famous result called Thales' theorem.
Let us start by constructing line segments $C_mB_m$, $B_oC_o$, $C_mB_o$ and $C_oB_m$.




Now in $\triangle OBC$, we use midpoint theorem to conclude $B_oC_o$ is parallel to $BC$. Similarly in $\triangle ABC$ we get $C_mB_m$ is parallel to $BC$. Similarly by considering $\triangle AOC$ and $\triangle AOB$, we get $C_mB_o$ and $C_oB_m$ are parallel (since both are parallel to $AO$ by midpoint theorem). Since line $AO$ (ie line $AA_a$ is perpendicular to $BC$, we get $C_oB_m$ is perpendicular to $C_mB_m$. So, $\square C_mB_mC_oB_o$ is a rectangle and in particular is a cyclic quadrilateral. Moreover, by converse of Thales' theorem, $C_mC_o$ and $B_mB_o$ are the diameters of the circle passing through vertices of $\square C_mB_mC_oB_o$. Again by converse of Thales' theorem, $C_a$ and $B_a$ also lie on this circle.

We have proved that $C_m,B_m,C_o,B_o,C_a, B_a$ lie on a circle with diameters $C_mC_o$ and $B_mB_o$. Similarly, we can show $A_m,B_m,A_o,B_o,A_a, B_a$ lie on a circle with diameters $A_mA_o$ and $B_mB_o$ and $A_m,C_m,A_o,C_o,A_a, C_a$ lie on a circle with diameters $A_mA_o$ and $C_mC_o$. Looking at the diameters of these three circles, we see that any two of them has a common diameter. So these three circles must coincide and is indeed the required nine point circle.

References:
  •  A Sequel to the First Six Books of Euclid by John Casey
  • David Joyce's web version of Euclid's Elements



Sunday, 25 June 2023

Riemann Sphere and Stereographic Projection

Sometimes while studying complex valued functions, it is sometimes useful to consider the extended complex plane $\mathbb{C} \cup \{ \infty \}$, where we append an additional point $\infty$ to the set of usual complex numbers. This is especially helpful in study of Mobius maps $z \mapsto \frac{az+b}{cz+d}$ where $ad-bc \not = 0$.

Riemann sphere provides us with a model of extended complex plane. This makes it in useful in complex analysis because it allows us to make sense of division by zero in some circumstance ($\frac{0}{0}$ is still undefined).

We start with the unit sphere $S^2$ in $\mathbb{R}^3$ ie. the spherical surface with center at origin and unit radius (set of points $(x,y,z)$ given by $x^2 +y^2 +z^2=1$). First, we shall show there is a bijection between the $R^2$ and $S^2$ minus a single point. (We identity $xy$-plane with $\mathbb{R}^2$)

Start with a point $P$ on $S^2$ other than the north pole $N = (0,0,1)$. Draw a ray starting from $N$ passing through $P$. This ray will intersect the $xy$-plane at a unique point $Q$. The map that takes $P$ to $Q$ is called as stereographic projection and is denoted as $\Pi$.


We shall use some properties of vectors to derive stereographic projection explicitly. $Q - N$ is parallel to $P - N$, so $P - N = k(Q - N)$ for some scalar $k$. Denote $P=(x,y,z)$ and $Q=(u,v,0)$. Then, we get $(x,y,z) = (ku,kv,1-k)$ so that $k=1-z$. Note $z \not = 1$ since $P \not = N$.

$$\therefore \Pi (x,y,z) = (u,v,0) = \left( \frac{x}{1-z}, \frac{y}{1-z}, 0 \right)$$

Since $x^2 + y^2 + z^2 = 1$, we have $k^2u^2 + k^2v^2 + (1-k)^2 = 1$. Simplifying (while noting $k \not = 0$ since $z \not = 1$),

$$k = \frac{2}{u^2+v^2 +1}$$

$$\therefore P = (x,y,z) = \left(  \frac{2u}{u^2+v^2 +1}, \frac{2v}{u^2+v^2 +1}, \frac{u^2 +v^2 -1}{u^2+v^2 +1} \right)$$

It takes some simple calculations to verify that $\Pi : S^2 \setminus \{ N \} \to \mathbb{R}^2$ is a bijection and the map $ (u,v,0) \mapsto \left(  \frac{2u}{u^2+v^2 +1}, \frac{2v}{u^2+v^2 +1}, \frac{u^2 +v^2 -1}{u^2+v^2 +1} \right)$ is its inverse.


Interact with GeoGebra applet to see how stereographic projection actually works.

In fact our map $\Pi$ is conformal (ie. it preserves angles) but proof of this assertion requires some tools from differential geometry.

We can extend $\Pi$ to the whole sphere $S^2$ by simply defining $\Pi (N) = \infty$. Here, $\infty$ is just a symbol. And similarly extend $\Pi^{-1} :  \mathbb{R}^2 \cup \{ \infty \} \mapsto S^2$. Since, we can interpret $ \mathbb{C}$ as  $\mathbb{R}^2$ (from a topological point of view), we can also define $\Pi^{-1} :  \mathbb{C} \cup \{ \infty \} \to S^2$ as $$z \mapsto \left(  \frac{2 \Re(z)}{|z|^2 +1}, \frac{2 \Im(z)}{|z|^2 +1}, \frac{|z|^2 -1}{|z|^2 +1} \right)$$

where $\Re(z)$ and $\Im(z)$ are real and imaginary part of $z$ respectively, and

$$\infty \mapsto (0,0,1)$$

PS: From a topological point of view, we can define a topology $\tau_1$ on $\mathbb{C} \cup \{\infty\}$ such that our usual topology $\tau_2$ on $\mathbb{C}$ is a subspace of  $\tau_1$ and $\tau_1$ is one point compactification of $\tau_2$.

References:

  • A Pathway to Complex Analysis by S. Kumaresan
  • Topology by J. Munkres
  • A Comprehensive introduction to Differential Geometry Vol. 2 by M. Spivak










Mathematical Biscuit I

 Can you find two irrational numbers $a,b$ such that $a^b$ is rational? Surprisingly, yes and the argument is very easy.  If $\sqrt{2}^{\sq...